Action executed in 0.000

On providing software feedback

I've been using Nagios at work to monitor services across the network. Yesterday's upgrade failed. After fixing that i had some wishes for Nagios that i wanted to pass on. So my question for everyone is do i as (let's pretend i'm) a beginner speak to Debian where i got the software, or directly to Nagios?

On a philosophical note, i've thought about this a bit. I get my software directly from Debian. And Debian gets it from upstream, say Mozilla. Now as an experienced Debian user, i know which bugs are application bug and which ones are packaging bugs. But does the beginner or novice know this? Should they know this? I don't think so. Keeping it simple for the software user would be having a central location where they can provide feedback on software. And it makes sense that this is the place where the they got the software.

Unfortunately this line of thinking implies more work for packagers, namely reading more submissions, evaluating them, and passing some or most of them upstream. In this light, Debian becomes a virtual user of the upstream software. Debian forwards bugs on behalf of the user to upstream.

I'm curious to know if this sort of forwarding communication is built into the Debian structure. I guess not since software providers have various bug reporting interfaces. It would be cool if there Debian could forward bugs to any Bugzilla repository.


There is, if only informally

tags: Debian, bug
You can submit your bugs to the Debian maintainers, and they'll handle it appropriately - see
parent post: On providing software feedback
notify me: yes

Post a Comment

* indicates a required field
anonymous (If you want to identify yourself, please sign in first.)
required This field is required.

Max size is 2 MB, aspect ratio 3:4 width:height
required This field is required.
Please include a short description.
required This field is required.

480 characters remaining.
is public

(Use this field if you have to. 3000 characters remaining.)
1 penny, 2 nickels, 1 dime + 100

Trackback URL